Nick Herbig’s 2025 Fantasy Outlook, Is He a Must-Add for Your Roster?

Quick Answer

Nick Herbig is not a must-add for standard 12-team fantasy football leagues, but he is a high-upside stash in deeper leagues or formats that reward individual defensive players (IDP). His 2025 breakout season—finishing seventh among 115 qualified edge defenders in PFF defensive grade (86.7) and recording 15 sacks—proves he's more than a flash-in-the-pan rotational player.

However, his role behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith caps his weekly consistency.

• Best for: Deep IDP leagues (16+ teams) and dynasty managers looking for a long-term edge rusher with elite pass-rush efficiency.
• Key point: Herbig led the NFL in pass-rush win rate in 2025, per multiple league sources, and signed a four-year, $100 million extension with $42 million guaranteed.
• Bottom line: If you have roster space, add him now. If you're in a shallow league, wait and monitor his snap share early in the 2026 season.

---

The Numbers That Demand Your Attention

Let's cut through the noise. Nick Herbig is not just a "good backup" anymore.

The data from the 2025 season paints a picture of a player who produced at an elite level despite not being a full-time starter. Here's the raw output you need to know:

Metric	2025 Season Value	NFL Rank (Edge Defenders)
PFF Overall Defensive Grade	86.7	7th of 115
PFF Pass-Rush Grade	87.1	8th of 115
PFF Run-Defense Grade	71.4	23rd of 115
Total Sacks	15.0	Top 10 (exact rank unconfirmed)
Total Pressures	47	High-efficiency rate
Forced Fumbles	9	League leader candidate
Total Tackles	77	Strong for part-time role

The 15 sacks and 9 forced fumbles are franchise-changing numbers for a player who wasn't even a starter for the entire season. To put that in perspective: Herbig forced more fumbles in 2025 than most starting edge rushers do in two seasons.

His 86.7 overall grade places him in the company of established stars, and the Steelers recognized that value by locking him up with a massive extension. If you're still holding a roster spot for a "proven veteran" who puts up 4 sacks a season, you're losing ground.

Herbig's efficiency metrics suggest that even if his snap count doesn't skyrocket, his per-play production will remain elite. That's exactly the kind of player you want in an IDP flex spot—someone who can win a game for you with a single strip-sack.

But here's the catch: volume matters. Herbig's 77 tackles are solid, but not elite for IDP scoring.

If your league rewards tackles heavily, he's a tier below the every-down linebackers. However, in big-play scoring formats (sacks, forced fumbles, touchdowns), he's a top-10 asset.

---

The Contract Confirms the Arrival

The most significant development for Herbig's fantasy value happened on Tuesday, when the Steelers and Herbig agreed to a four-year, $100 million contract extension that includes $42 million guaranteed. Let that sink in: a player who was drafted in the fourth round of the 2023 NFL draft just got paid like a top-15 edge rusher in the league.

Why does this matter for your fantasy roster? First, it ends any trade speculation.

There were rumors—and even an article from The Sporting News suggesting the Eagles should trade for him—that Herbig might seek a starting role elsewhere. His agent made it clear publicly: "Nick wants to be a Pittsburgh Steeler for life." The contract backs that up.

Herbig is staying in Pittsburgh, and the Steelers are building their defense around him alongside T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith.

Second, the financial commitment guarantees that the coaching staff will find ways to get him on the field. You don't pay a backup $100 million.

Expect Herbig's snap count to increase in 2026, even if he remains the third outside linebacker in base packages. The Steelers will rotate their edge rushers more aggressively to keep all three fresh and productive.

Third, it signals that Herbig's 2025 season was not a fluke. General managers don't hand out $42 million guaranteed based on a single year of luck.

The Steelers' internal analytics and PFF's grades (86.7 overall, 87.1 pass-rush) confirm that Herbig is a legitimate top-10 edge rusher when given the opportunity. For fantasy managers, this contract is a buy signal.

The commitment is real. The production is real.

The only question is how many snaps he'll see in 2026.

---

The Role Reality Why He's Not T.J. Watt (Yet)

Let's be honest: the biggest obstacle to Herbig's fantasy value is that he plays behind arguably the best defensive player in the NFL (T.J. Watt) and a very good starter in Alex Highsmith.

In 2024, Herbig recorded 13 tackles and 5.5 sacks before a hamstring injury sidelined him. In 2025, he broke out with 15 sacks, but he still wasn't a full-time starter.

Here's the role breakdown based on available data:

• 2024 (pre-injury): Herbig played roughly 35-40% of defensive snaps in the first five games, recording 2.5 sacks and 8 tackles before the hamstring injury.
• 2025: His snap share likely increased to around 50-55% after his return and the contract extension.
• 2026 outlook: Expect 55-65% snap share as the Steelers rotate their trio of edge rushers.

The Steelers have a "good problem," as one source noted: they have three starting-caliber outside linebackers. T.J.

Watt and Alex Highsmith are the starters, with Herbig being the third. That creates a ceiling on his weekly fantasy output.

Even if he's the most efficient pass rusher on the team, he can't produce 15 sacks every year if he's not on the field for 80% of snaps. However, there's a counterargument that makes Herbig a smart add: injury upside.

T.J. Watt has missed games in previous seasons due to various injuries.

Highsmith has also dealt with ankle and groin issues. If either starter misses time, Herbig immediately becomes a top-10 IDP play.

He proved in 2025 that he can be the focal point of a defense. For a Pittsburgh Steelers Player Profile Fantasy Football Magazine, Herbig would be listed as a "high-risk, high-reward" pick in the late rounds.

If you're using a NFL Team Logo Fantasy Football Draft Board, mark him as a target in rounds 18-20 of a standard draft. He's not a league-winner on his own, but he's the kind of player who can swing a playoff matchup with a multi-sack game.

---

The Hamstring History A Cautionary Tale

Every fantasy analyst will tell you that injuries are unpredictable, but patterns matter. Herbig's injury history is short but notable:

• November 2024: Suffered a hamstring injury in a Monday night win over the Dolphins. Missed three weeks before returning in Week 17 against the Cleveland Browns. He practiced in full on Friday and was cleared with no injury designation.
• 2025 season: FOX Sports lists a hamstring injury as "Questionable" at one point, but he played through it and produced his 15-sack season.

The good news: hamstring injuries, while frustrating, are not structural or degenerative. Herbig is a 24-year-old athlete (born November 21, 2001) who has fully recovered and returned to elite production.

The 2024 injury cost him three games, but he bounced back and had his best season in 2025. The caution: soft-tissue injuries can recur, especially for explosive pass rushers who rely on sudden bursts off the line.

Herbig's game is built on speed and bend around the edge. A tight hamstring can rob him of that explosiveness for weeks at a time.

For your fantasy decision, this means:

1. Draft him with confidence but monitor his practice participation during training camp.
2. Stash him on your bench early in the season if you have the roster space.
3. Sell high if he starts 2026 with a hot streak (3-4 sacks in the first month). The injury history might scare off some trade partners, but his production is real.

A practical tool for draft day: an NFL Fantasy Football Cheat Sheet Poster that includes Herbig as a late-round target with a "high ceiling, moderate floor" note. He's not a must-start, but he's a must-own in leagues with 12 or more teams.

---

How to Add Him to Your Roster Right Now

You've read the data. You've seen the contract.

You understand the role. Now here's your action plan for June 2, 2026:

Step 1: Check your league settings.

• If your league uses IDP with 2+ defensive spots, Herbig should be rostered in 90% of leagues.
• If your league is offense-only, stop reading—Herbig has no value for you.
• If your league uses team defenses (D/ST), Herbig's individual stats don't matter, but the Steelers' D/ST gets a boost from his presence.

Step 2: Evaluate your current IDP roster.

• Do you have a top-5 edge rusher (Micah Parsons, T.J. Watt, Myles Garrett)? If yes, Herbig is a luxury stash.
• Do you have a streamer at edge rusher? Herbig is an immediate upgrade.
• Is your IDP bench full of middle-tier linebackers? Drop the lowest-upside player and add Herbig.

Step 3: Monitor the Steelers' training camp reports.

• Watch for any mentions of Herbig lining up on the interior on passing downs—that would increase his snap share.
• Track his practice participation. Full participation in June means he's healthy.
• Look for quotes from Mike Tomlin about "getting our best players on the field." That's code for three-edge-rusher packages.

Step 4: Be patient. Herbig might not be a top-10 scorer every week. He might have 0.5 sacks in a game where Watt and Highsmith combine for 3.

That's fine. His value is in the peaks—the 2-sack, 1-forced-fumble games that win your matchup single-handedly.

If you're in a dynasty league, he's a hold for the next 3-4 years. The $100 million contract keeps him in Pittsburgh through at least 2029.

He's 24 years old with an elite pass-rush grade. The trajectory is clear.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Nick Herbig's current fantasy value for the 2026 season?

Herbig is a mid-tier IDP edge rusher with elite upside. His 2025 season (15 sacks, 9 forced fumbles, 86.7 PFF grade) proves he can produce at an elite level on a per-snap basis.

However, his role behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith caps his weekly floor.

In standard IDP scoring (1 point per tackle, 3 per sack, 2 per forced fumble), he projects as a low-end EDGE1 or high-end EDGE2. In big-play-heavy scoring formats, he's a top-10 option.

Did Nick Herbig really sign a $100 million contract?

Yes. Multiple sources, including NFL Network and ESPN, reported that Herbig agreed to a four-year, $100 million contract extension with the Pittsburgh Steelers.

The deal includes $42 million guaranteed. This makes him one of the highest-paid backup edge rushers in NFL history, though his role is expected to expand.

Is Nick Herbig a starter for the Steelers in 2026?

No, not in the traditional sense. T.J.

Watt and Alex Highsmith remain the starters. However, the Steelers have increasingly used three-edge-rusher packages, especially on passing downs.

Herbig's snap share is expected to rise to 55-65% in 2026, up from roughly 50% in 2025. He is effectively a "starter" in sub-packages.

How did Herbig perform in college?

Herbig played college football at the University of Wisconsin. He was selected by the Steelers in the fourth round of the 2023 NFL draft.

He attended Saint Louis School in Oahu, Hawaii. Specific college stats are not provided in the available web content, but his draft capital (4th round) suggests he was a productive college player who needed development.

What should I do if I already have T.J. Watt rostered?

That's an interesting scenario. If you own Watt, you might be hesitant to roster Herbig because they compete for sacks on the same defense.

However, the Steelers' defense is good enough to support multiple fantasy-relevant edge rushers. In 2025, Watt and Herbig both had strong seasons.

Pairing them gives you a hedge against injury and a dominant pass-rush duo in a good matchup. If you have the roster space, it's a smart play.

Fact-check References

This article draws on publicly available reporting and official data. The links below are factual references only — not the source of wording or editorial opinion.

1. https://www.nfl.com/players/nick-herbig/stats — checked 2026-06-02
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Herbig — checked 2026-06-02
3. https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/gamelog/_/id/4429164/nick-herbig — checked 2026-06-02
4. https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/football/news/steelers-nick-herbig-picks-up-ha... — checked 2026-06-02
5. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q25Sy3QMCxY — checked 2026-06-02

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we believe in.